Mongolia: A Lucky but Difficult Pie to Slice


The rapid inflow of huge amounts of investment cash is forcefully dragging the small economy of Mongolia forward, despite numerous problems plaguing the Government and related crucial decision-making bodies.
Mongolia is probably one of the few lucky countries on earth. When the Manchus were defeated by the Red Soviets and left Mongolian territories and its people alone, Mongolia’s fate was at the mercy of the Russians. Due to the Russian belief in expanding their political and economic views, Mongolia became the second communist country in the world and luckily, for over 70 years we were nurtured under the benefit of being a comrade of the Soviets and our nearly extinct population of mere half a million grew to over two million and modern concrete buildings built all around the country.
Great luck has struck us again, this time in the form of our mineral resources.
Mongolia’s potential for economic growth is great, just like its great political and economic instabilities and risks, but apparently the financial benefits for the ones who help Mongolia to realize its potential seems even greater. Yet this process appears that it will be a long and hard journey.
We are sometimes referred to as “beggars sitting on gold” and ironically that phrase definitely has some truth to it. Mongolia has a colossal amount of mineral resources beneath its soil. Oyu Tolgoi will be the largest copper mine in the world outside Chile, while the Tavan Tolgoi mine has one of the largest coal deposits in the world. But how can Mongolia, a country which only just recently made an aggressive but prompt transition from a socialist economy to that of a free-market one and saw the disappearance of dozens of industries overnight, realize its potential?
It has been a hard haul since 1990 to come here into the 21st century with our previous rather slow development in the economy. By that time, we realized what riches were under us and that we did not have the manpower to dig them up; and we also calculated how much money (which we came to also realize that we do not have) it would take to get them out. So Ivanhoe Mines steps in and proposes they would dig them up for us and in return, they would get a share of the profits.
For a few years, Ivanhoe Mines and its investors poured money into Mongolia until they ‘ran out.’ Ivanhoe Mines negotiated financing deals with Rio Tinto, and ultimately Ivanhoe Mines CEO Robert Friedland stepped down and Ivanhoe Mines was taken over by Rio Tinto, effectively placing the development responsibility of Oyu Tolgoi on Rio Tinto.
Mongolia’s only real job in this seems pretty simple: maintain healthy foreign relations and develop careful investment laws and policies and let Rio Tinto what they need to do.
Now in addition to having the Soviets build our basic infrastructure, we will have Australians dig up our minerals for our own benefit.
Mongolia’s business and political environment has been labeled as ‘risky and unstable.’ It still is considered so, might be even worse than previously thought, given the occurrence of certain events involving SouthGobi Sands and Sarah Armstrong lately.
According to the Michigan State University Risk Assessment on Mongolia, both the business and country rating for Mongolia was considered a ‘C,’ with ‘A’ being the highest rating. The report states that Mongolia’s business environment is “difficult,” and continuing “corporate financial information is often not available and when available often unreliable. Debt collection is unpredictable. The institutional framework has many troublesome weaknesses. Intercompany transactions run major risks in the difficult environment rated C.”
With no official word from authorities on the situation with Sarah Armstrong and her being considered a witness in a case involving SouthGobi Sands, it may further prove the instability of the business and political environment of Mongolia.
Rio Tinto has already put a lot into the project; all it will have to do is just bear through this, taking whatever measures are necessary. Mongolia could be an easy pie to slice for investors but with the way things are heading, it does not seem it will be that way.

Short URL: http://ubpost.mongolnews.mn/?p=1668

Posted by on Oct 29 2012. Filed under Opinion. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

3 Comments for “Mongolia: A Lucky but Difficult Pie to Slice”

  1. [...] Mongolia: A Lucky but Difficult Pie to Slice For a few years, Ivanhoe Mines and its investors poured money into Mongolia until they 'ran out.' Ivanhoe Mines negotiated financing deals with Rio Tinto, and ultimately Ivanhoe Mines CEO Robert Friedland stepped down and Ivanhoe Mines was taken over … Read more on UB Post [...]

  2. Actually everything written here is sugar coated. The government is corrupted to the very own system, to the very own core. But as always a system has lots of pieces. Like a building brick. Even though one brick can be destroyed the other ones will hold the building. That’s why the country is still being coined as a ‘developing country’. There are few good people in the ‘high seat’ and they are trying to keep the country standing. But a building will collapse if many blocks are removed…

  3. Mongolia (its politicians) needs to grow up and realize that they have no choice but to learn to deal with and operate at global legal and governance standards.

    The only real asset Mongolia has is it minerals and they are too complex to be self developed. Mongolia has neither the human capital nor the technical expertise nor the investment capital to develop its assets. The mineral assets require long term capital intensive investments that will not occur without a stable and consistent regulatory legal and political environment

    Mongolia also needs to learn to deal with China – basic geography and Mongolia’s landlocked remote and inaccessible location means that there are no alternative for transport intense commodities (coal) to go other than China

    Time for Mongolian politicians to grow up

Leave a Reply to Ivanhoe Mines Ltd. News: Groups to celebrate, honor veterans... - Top TSX Stocks

+ 3 = 10

Recently Commented

  • Oyun: www.theblueeconomy.org
  • Honheree: It is a sad and awful sight to see so many animals dead from dzuds. These have happened in the past and since 2004 there have...
  • Harvey Dent: Mongolia does not get 476,000 tourists a year. Its gets 476,000 arrivals, most of these are Chinese construction workers....
  • Honheree: It is good but unusual that a Mongolian is so forthright. I am D. Ganbold will be criticised by Mongolians for telling the...
  • Honheree: Be thankful Mongolia is so cheap. In USA lamb in stores costs 69,281 MNT /kg and sirloin which is cheaper cut of beef is...